Fairy Tales vs. Horror: The Origins and Evolution

The Origins of Fairy Tales

Most of the fairy tales we are familiar with have their roots in European folklore, dating back to the Middle Ages. Originally, fairy tales were not intended for children. The concept of childhood as a distinct phase of life didn't emerge until the 17th century, and prior to that, children were often treated as "mini adults." Consequently, many fairy tales were dark and violent, designed to impart moral lessons about danger, punishment, and reward. These tales often blended elements of horror, a literary genre that also emerged during this period, with themes of fear, the supernatural, and the unknown.

The Emergence of Childhood and Fairy Tales for Children

As childhood began to be recognized as a distinct phase of life, a new market for children's literature was born. The first significant fairy tale collections were published within this context.

Charles Perrault: Shaping Fairy Tales for Children

Charles Perrault, a French poet and lawyer, was one of the first to collect and adapt folklore for a broader audience in the 17th century. His works, such as Sleeping Beauty, Little Red Riding Hood, and Puss in Boots, laid the groundwork for what we now recognize as children's literature. Perrault's adaptations softened the original folk tales, focusing on more idealized versions of good versus evil.

The Brothers Grimm: Preserving Oral Folklore

Jacob and Wilhelm Grimm, German scholars, collected and published a vast array of oral stories during their research. Inspired by Perrault, they sought to preserve these tales in written form. Their famous collection includes Hansel and Gretel, Snow White, and The Golden Goose. However, the Grimms altered these stories to make them more palatable to their audience, often removing excessive violence and incorporating elements of Christian morality and Romantic ideals.

Hans Christian Andersen: Emotional Complexity in Fairy Tales

Hans Christian Andersen, a Danish author, took a similar approach to the Brothers Grimm but with a more melancholic tone. His tales often presented complex emotional narratives, with protagonists facing sadness, loss, and hardship. While many fairy tales emphasize a moral lesson with a happy ending, Andersen's stories sometimes ended in tragedy, underscoring the emotional depth and the harsh realities of life.

Angela Carter: Reimagining Fairy Tales

Angela Carter, in her book The Bloody Chamber, offers a radically different perspective on traditional fairy tales. Carter's works go beyond the simple moral lessons often associated with fairy tales, exploring themes of power, sexuality, and subordination. In her retellings, the passive, innocent female characters of traditional fairy tales become empowered, often challenging societal norms and seeking personal freedom.

By rewriting these stories, Carter also brings sexuality into the foreground, exploring themes of violence, desire, and fear in ways that were previously less overt. Her stories present a more intense, complex view of good and evil, inviting readers to critically examine traditional gender roles and social structures. For Carter, fairy tales are not just for children; they are a tool for understanding deeper societal dynamics.

The Classic vs. The Dark: The Transformation of Fairy Tales

Angela Carter's reimagining of fairy tales opens new possibilities, questioning traditional narratives. For instance, what if Little Red Riding Hood wanted to meet the wolf rather than fear him? Or, what if Bluebeard were an aesthete, collecting art and women as objects? These questions allow us to see fairy tales through a more critical lens, revealing darker, more complex interpretations.

Dark Interpretations of Classic Fairy Tales

While Carter's work brings a darker layer to fairy tales, there are numerous earlier versions of these stories that were also filled with disturbing details. Let's take a look at some of these darker, original versions:

In Giambattista Basile's earlier version, the princess is found unconscious by a king who rapes her and she later gives birth to twins. This version is far darker than the later adaptations by Perrault and the Brothers Grimm, where the princess is awakened by a kiss from her true love and lives happily ever after.

In Hans Christian Andersen's original version, the mermaid sacrifices her voice to gain legs in the hope of marrying a prince, only to have him marry another woman. Rather than seeking revenge, the mermaid chooses self-sacrifice and turns into sea foam. This tragic ending contrasts with the more well-known version, where the mermaid is saved by the prince and lives happily ever after.

Conclusion: Fairy Tales as a Reflection of Society

Fairy tales, from their dark and violent origins to their more sanitized modern versions, continue to evolve, reflecting the changing concerns and values of society. Authors like Charles Perrault, the Brothers Grimm, Hans Christian Andersen, and Angela Carter have shaped and reshaped these stories, exploring themes of morality, power, and human nature. Whether through traditional tales or dark reimaginings, fairy tales remain a mirror to society, reflecting both the light and dark aspects of our world.

Sources: